Tiger or thriver: which parenting style are you?
- Posted by:
- Michael Grose
There’s been a lot of media and online blog focus given to parenting styles in the last few months.
Much of this attention to parenting is due to the release of a controversial book The Battle hymn of the Tiger Mother by American author Amy Chua earlier this year.
Yale law professor Amy Chua described how she raised her kids using a ruthless parenting style that flies in face of current Western practice. For example, she told how she forced her 7-year-old daughter Lulu to practise a tune on the piano for hours on end — "right through dinner into the night," with no breaks for water or even the bathroom, until at last Lulu learned to play the piece.
Chua in interviews has been scathing of the current western parenting approach that allows kids to waste hours of time on Facebook and computer games, rather than spending valuable time preparing them for the future. “It’s a tough world out there!” she announced on American Today Show earlier this year.
Her stories of never accepting a mark lower than an A, of insisting on hours of math and spelling drills and daily piano practice (weekends and vacations included), of not allowing sleepovers or television or computer games have left many readers bewildered, but also defensive.
“Where’s the love and the acceptance?”
seems to sum up the response by many outraged readers on blogs and newspapers. At a time when many parents are labeled as ‘helicopter’, ‘pushy’ or even ‘pushovers’ Chua’s Tiger parenting mantra has certainly hit a nerve. The implications are that the tiger mother’s cubs will be better prepared to hit the world running than those who experience an indulgent, permissive parenting style. You could say it’s a book whose time has come!
The fact that Chua has presented an alternate parenting view is to be applauded, although some of her methods don’t sit well with most professionals and educators. Her views are also highly subjective.
What does the evidence say?
There’s plenty of empirical evidence to suggest a more balanced parenting approach produces the best outcomes from kids. The recent Millennium Study mapped the parenting styles of 9,000 English households and found that children who experience authoritative (Thriving) parenting are best prepared to do well in life.
An analysis of the results is revealing. One quarter of kids with authoritative parents (Thriving parenting) were in the top 20 per cent at school. Next came permissive parenting with 18 per cent, 15 per cent for authoritarian (Tiger parenting) and 11 per cent of this cohort going to kids of disengaged parents.
The authoritative approach offers a mix of discipline and warmth that is deemed necessary for kids to thrive, thus it’s been dubbed the Thriving Link to book approach.
Here are five characteristics of the Thriving (authoritative) style:
1. Parents set limits and boundaries that expand as kids get older and become more capable.
2. Parents use consequences and other tools to teach kids to behave well and develop a sense of personal responsibility.
3. Children receive a great deal of encouragement (comments directed at improvement, effort and contribution rather than directed at their ability) and quality feedback about their efforts and behaviour that helps them improve.
4. Parents encourage empathy in children by recognising their emotions and giving them permission and assistance to express their feelings and help them resolve relationship problems.
5. Parents put a range of measures in place to develop a sense of generosity of spirit and give and take so kids think ‘we’ rather than ‘what’s in it for me?’ This sense of community that authoritative parenting promotes is the real strength of the style.
Parenting style is not necessarily fixed. It changes over time according to children’s needs, our wellbeing and even their ages.
Common sense suggests parents need to be stricter with some children than with others and there will be times when parents need to release the pressure on kids, and adopt a more permissive approach for a time. However most of us default to a particular style and it would seem that most kids do better when their parents are more thrivers than tigers.
Want to know if you’re a tiger
Take my FREE Which Parenting Style Are You?
Parenting quiz at www.Parentingideas.com.au/parents
and discover whether you’r more tiger or thriver. There are also some practical implementation ideas as well. You can also tell me on the web poll if you are a tiger or a thriver.
Subscribe to Michael's blog